Econsultancy criticises online checkouts

Argues forcing registration is a "barrier to purchase"

Econsultancy criticises online store checkouts
HMV has responded to Econsultancy, saying it will improve aspects of its checkout process

Econsultancy editor Graham Charlton has warned that online stores are putting up unnecessary barriers to purchase. In his article 'Why HMV shouldn't make users register before checkout', Charlton criticises HMV's checkout process. Armed with a gift voucher and offer from a deals website, he went to the HMV site, but found he had to create an account before he could redeem his codes (rather than being able to redeem them when checking out). He also became entangled in an issue with an account reset, having forgotten his account’s details.

According to a recent Econsultancy/Toluna study, these kinds of actions annoy and frustrate users. Over 25 per cent of potential customers abandon purchases when being forced to register on a site before buying anything, and Charlton therefore suggests alternatives, such as optional registration before purchase, registration during checkout, or no registration at all. An earlier article on the site by Paul Rouke noted that ASOS halved its checkout abandonment by removing mentions of creating an account.

Given that the current economic climate makes people reluctant to spend money, web designers and developers must minimise barriers to purchase or their clients will count the cost. In addition to Charlton's points, consider how many form fields you force customers to fill in; make the process as fast, user-friendly and seamless as possible; and minimise unnecessary marketing. Judging by the comments in Charlton's piece, HMV's seen the light: PR head Gennaro Castaldo said the article made valid points and that the company was already in the process of addressing them. "I trust you'll soon be able to see a significant improvement in our online purchasing/check out processes as well as other site changes," he added.

Have you been involved with online stores and check-out processes? What would you recommend, in order to maximise orders and sales? Let us know in the comments!

4 comments

Comment: 1

Hi Craig, Thanks for the coverage. I had to register to leave this comment ;)

Comment: 3

I believe that for any website that sells real world goods the user should not need to register an account at any stage.

For digital goods it is a slightly different matter as the purchased item may need to be used via an online service which then entails authentication and checking the user owns the item and so forth, so a link between the user and the item has to be made at some stage.

Comment: 4

This all sounds good and well, but I have yet to see any proof that Guest Checkout actually works. In A/B testing Guest Checkout has only shown to improve abandonment rates at the login level. Oddly, users who use Guest options, do not appear to complete their purchase. At least not that I have been able to show. Even Forrester Research doesn't have any hard numbers to support that Guest checkout actually helps the online retailer. The question is of course 'why'. There is countless anecdotal evidence, that users so clearly favor and in fact demand Guest checkout, so why, when it's offered do they abandon the purchase? What might they be expecting down the line, during checkout, that we are not providing?
July issue on sale now!

The Week in Web Design

Sign up to our 'Week in Web Design' newsletter!

Hosting Directory
.net digital edition
Treat yourself to our geeky merchandise!
site stat collection