Anti-EU cookie law protest site launched

Software company Silktide launches site arguing new law will put EU companies at a disadvantage

Silktide launches anti-EU cookie law protest site
No Cookie Law: hoping to make the EU cookie law less ridiculous

Software company Silktide has launched No Cookie Law, a website protesting a new EU law that will make the use of cookies illegal if a site doesn't ask for permission before using them.

According to Silktide MD Oliver Emberton, the law will render “social buttons, analytics and discussion systems like Disqus impossible to use without interrupting the user with a pop-up or slide-out banner,” and he told .net that non-EU rivals “have no such restriction, and so good luck competing with them”.

Such a statement might seem dramatic, but Emberton said you have to bear in mind what typical internet users will see: “Imagine every supermarket had to ask customers to sign a waiver to enter their store, granting permission to monitor them and track their purchases. We'd expect people to walk out, and even those who comply will be annoyed. Now imagine only some supermarkets have that restriction. That's this law in a nutshell.”

In an attempt to combat the changes, No Cookie Law was launched. “We're a small software company and our customers are mostly web designers, and the law is a nightmare for all of us. While plenty of people have objected to the law, we've yet to see any kind of coordinated protest. So we decided to start one,” explained Emberton.

Although the law clearly impacts on clients and users, Emberton noted that developers will also be affected: “You might get a rush of new work, but it’ll mostly be to make websites worse.” He added that only a month from the law coming into effect, a KPMG study said 95 per cent of UK sites are not compliant, and that could lead to clients blaming agencies and developers for not making them aware of the changes in law.

There’s a sense of inevitability about the legislation, but No Cookie Law is worth checking out, as Emberton told us: “We've started a petition and more. No-one can stop the law by themselves, but if we work together, we can make it enormously unpopular – and that's a step towards changing it.”

3 comments

Comment: 1

Regarding your piece about EU Cookie Law and the cost to business there is a very quick/easy to implement and low cost solution to this that you may not be aware of called CookieTab please see..
 
http://www.eu-cookie-law.com/

Comment: 2

@DoubleSpeed - It's not really about the cost of implementing scripts to make a site compliant. There are even already free scripts online that can handle this. The whole point of it is that EU businesses that sell online have an extra barriere now with this 'opt-in to consent ' compared to their competitors outside the EU.

Wether it's a toolbar, slide-out panel or popup... it's just an extra step (and an annoying one) a visitor has to take before they can use the website to its full potential. Cookies are also used to enhance the user experience. Take for example the 'remember me' thick box in login forms. It's a handy one, because you don't have to type your email address again. A regular user doesn't know about those handy cookies, because how many visitors do actually read privacy statements where those cookies are used for. All they know is that they heard/read some stories about Facebook, Google, Vodaphone or whatever evil company that use cookies that track you down on your way to the toilet and trying to sell you some stuff (through ads) along the way..

So EU companies can put nice disclaimers and privacy statements about their useful cookies next to the 'op-tin to consent' yes/no buttons, but all a visitor will read is 'evil cookie' and clicks on 'no'.

Comment: 3

@Doublespeed - Having checked out your link and read your notice (which states: "one or more cookies will already have been set when you loaded this page") it just looks like you are immediately ignoring one of the two requirements of the new legislation by failing to obtain consent before "storing information in the terminal equipment of a user".

Surely CookieTab should only appear when there are no cookies set by that page, rather than appearing after they've been set?
July issue on sale now!

The Week in Web Design

Sign up to our 'Week in Web Design' newsletter!

Hosting Directory
.net digital edition
Treat yourself to our geeky merchandise!
site stat collection