Designing experiences for women

Designing experiences for women

Women rule the web, make the majority of purchasing decisions, and are more active on social media channels than their male counterparts. And yet, as designers, we don’t know how to reach this target audience effectively

If you’re reading this, you’re probably male, since the majority of people in the web design field are men. But did you know that the majority of your user base is probably female? And are you sure you’re designing for them in a way that’s effective and not insulting or dismissive? Women are an important audience, and not one to be ignored. Understanding them and designing for them effectively is difficult, but it can be done.

Globally, women now make or influence 65 per cent of global consumer purchases. In the United States, they control 80 per cent of consumer spending. They’re the primary decision makers when it comes to adopting services, using online experiences, and purchasing products. They also dominate social media. 58 per cent of Facebook’s users are women, and 71 per cent of daily active users are women. Even if you have a product or site for men, women are likely influencing whether or not that product or site experience is adopted. That said, are you sure you know and understand women as an audience? Are you reaching them effectively? Do you know how and why behavior varies based upon gender? The solution to reaching a female audience is not “shrinking and pinking” your products or dumbing content down, but rather an understanding of how women engage with products and websites differently than men.

Struggling to understand women as an audience is nothing new. Consider the 1955 Dodge La Femme. In post World War II America, advertisers realised that more households were adopting two cars – one for the husband, and one for the stay at home wife. In an effort to reach this new market, Dodge created the La Femme, a car with a pink exterior and floral interior that came with matching lipstick, purse, rain cape and rain hat. The car was discontinued after two years, since women seemed to want what everyone else wanted in a car: function over frills.

Fast forward to recent years and, unfortunately, designers are still making assumptions about what women want. In 2009, Dell launched a campaign to promote its mini netbook to women, which was accompanied by a microsite called Della. The site touted claims such as "use your mini to track calories, carbs, and protein with ease.” It had a “featured artist” section showcasing singer/songwriters and a “tech tips” section with videos for preparing recipes. Needless to say, many people reacted negatively to the campaign. Dell received quite a bit of backlash online and removed the site in less than two weeks.

Now that we’ve seen a few examples of what doesn’t work, what can we do that actually does work? The Femme Den is a group of industrial designers at Smart Design in New York city. They specialise in designing products and experiences for women. Lucky for us, they’ve published a few guidelines that we can adopt as Web designers. We can also pull some insight from the marketing field. Marketers have understood for years now that women primarily control spending and make household decisions. Holly Buchanan’s blog Marketing to Women Online and the book Don’t Think Pink are two great sources for information on gender and marketing. Here’s a handy list of guidelines aggregated from the sources above.

Emphasise benefits over features or specs

Most women couldn’t care less about horse power, RAM, processors and chips. But they do care about how products help them. Rather than explaining the technical details of your product, tell her how the product is going to solve problems for her or make her life better. If you’re selling her a laptop, tell her how portable it is and how easy it is to manage photos and music.

Craft a holistic story

Most women are empathetic by nature and think on behalf of others when buying or adopting products. They buy and adopt for their children, spouses and partners, but they also do on behalf of extended family, coworkers and friends. If a product or experience can appeal to or extend to others in her life, be sure to tell her. A great example is a online calendar that allows her to see and manage her schedule as well as the schedules of her children and spouse or partner.

Another great example is the Nintendo Wii. Almost anyone can play and enjoy the Wii. If you were selling a Wii or a Wii game to women, you might want to tell them that everyone in the home can enjoy it. And beyond that, visitors – including friends, relatives, and neighbors of all ages – can enjoy it when they come over. If you don’t like your in-laws, stick them in the finished basement with the Wii so they can entertain themselves. Okay, that last one’s a stretch, but you get the idea.

Consider the full experience

Any marketing person will tell you that women pay close attention to every aspect of your brand. Let’s say that you’re a retailer, and your in-store experience is as top notch as it gets. That’s wonderful, but if your website is frustratingly difficult to use and useless at fulfilling her needs, she’ll notice and remember. Be sure to consider every aspect of your experience from start to finish. She pays attention and certainly shares her thoughts about negative experiences with others.

Culturally, we’ve been conditioned to associate women with frills, the color pink, and dumbed down content. But women are multi-dimensional people who demand useful and fulfilling experiences. Be sure to understand this crucial audience and how their needs and behaviours differ from that of men. If you’d like to learn more, check out the 2010 ComScore report Women on the Web: How Women are Shaping the Internet. Femme Den also published a series of articles on Gender and Design. Together we can make the web more useful for everyone, including women and not a splash of pink is required.

16 comments

Comment: 1

I’m not sure how saying, ‘Most women couldn’t care less about horse power, RAM, processors and chips… If you’re selling her a laptop, tell her how portable it is and how easy it is to manage photos and music.” is any less insulting than when Dell said their laptop could be used to count calories.

Comment: 2

@Jess: It's much less insulting. A) because it leads with the word "most", not "all" and B)That conclusion is likely based on data analysis and usage profiles, not guesswork. Would it be offensive if this article were about designing for men and it said "most men couldn't care less about cooking, clothing, or interior design"? I happen to be a man that enjoys all of those things, but I wouldn't be offended by that statement in the least, because it applies to the general demographic.

Comment: 3

The research may be based on 'most' but the article still advocates applying the principle to 'all'.

By saying that women don't care about RAM but they do care about how easy it is to use implies that they aren't able to look at the spec and interpret what that means for the performance of the machine. They need to be told 'THIS LAPTOP WORKS FAST' in explicit terms. If that isn't dumbing down, I'm not sure what is. It's a negative generalisation - unlike your clothes/cooking example which doesn't have any connotations.

Dell might have found from their research that 'most' women took an interest in their diet. The Della site still didn't go down too well.

We have to make generalisations sometimes in order to cater to the majority, but it's only really OK if those generalisations don't carry an insulting subtext.

Comment: 4

Thanks for your response, Jess.

I agree that you don't want to dumb down your content for women (or anyone for that matter). What's important is understanding the people you're trying to reach by speaking their language and giving them the information they want or need. Research has shown that most women just don't care about specs, features, and mechanics. There are exceptions to this, of course, but for the most part they just don't care. (We could argue why, but that's a separate discussion altogether.) What they do care about is understanding how a product is going to solve problems for them, make their lives easier, or help them get something done.

I wouldn't recommend removing specs or features entirely, but in most cases they shouldn't be as emphasized as the benefits.

Comment: 5

I'd also add that these are general guidelines. When possible, if you have the benefit of conducting user research for your specific audience, by all means do so. Although as a fellow experience designer, you don't need me to tell you that. ;) There are always exceptions to the general rules.

Comment: 6

Of course - 'sell the benefits not the features' - the number one rule of marketing, whoever your audience is. I'm not sure that's something we should only apply to women.

And that, I suppose, is my fundamental issue with your article - I don't agree with the principle of designing for the different genders. To me, it makes as much sense as 'designing experiences for gay people' or 'designing experiences for black people'. At best, it seems arbitrary and at worst, it could unhelpfully perpetuate the idea of divisions. I think audience profiling based on a number of characteristics is one thing, but lumping a whole gender in together is pushing it a bit.

But I can see from your area of expertise that that's not a view you share so I guess we'll have to agree to differ. :)

Comment: 7

"It's a negative generalisation - unlike your clothes/cooking example which doesn't have any connotations." To be fair, the comparison is completely equal as long as you take it for more than was said, like you did. With my example, I could easily take it as far as to say "men can't cook, dress themselves properly, or keep a house looking nice". Those things are all up to interpretation, and how they are presented by the designer/copywriter.

I'm all for gender equality and have had many great conversations regarding these types of issues, but I think that designing to trends and expectations for a pre-determined audience and verifiable data is far different than perpetuating stereotypes through blatantly sexist or misogynistic messaging.

Comment: 8

We want to create user experiences that suit our target audiences, and make it as comfortable and empowering for them as possible. If our target audience is mostly women, why shouldn't we be taking the calculated and data-driven steps to accommodate their web browsing preferences and tendencies? As we design to appeal to different levels of literacy, age groups, income brackets, and lifestyle pursuits, why shouldn't we consider designing for women-a massively influential web population-a priority?

I applaud Jessica Ivins for this article.

Cheers,
Sarah Bauer
Navigator Multimedia
www.navigatormm.com

Comment: 9

Thank you Jess, for voicing exactly what I (and I guess many other women) was thinking. Sad to see that even today, where many people even go as far as to suggest we’ve achieved gender equality, nobody will bat an eyelid to such gender segregation. :(

Comment: 10

Cheers for this extremely interesting blog post on web designing for women, looking past the stereotypes in this blog you can find some really interesting facts and advice which can help any designer create websites suitable for both sexes. I do like the sale tactics involved in this blog, i will try these out when trying to sell to clients in future, however i do feel that a line must be drawn between clever web sale tactics and ignorance to females.

Comment: 11

It's all good and well saying these things (they're probably tue), but where is the evidence? I'd have expected at least one research report per point e.g. the benefits over features. I know for example that Cheryl Platz from Microsoft has found that focusing on the human and problem solving side will help get girls into computing http://www.slideshare.net/cherylplatz/computer-engineer-barbie-how-interaction-design-can-entice-a-new-generation-of-women-6906531… where's the other stuff?

Comment: 13

If most of the web isn't being designed for us poor little girlies at the moment how come we use it so much? As a rampant tomboy (gosh I even build websites!) I suppose it's easier for me, but how the rest of the weaker sex manage it is probably more of a mystery.

Still I just won't bother my pretty little head about it all.

G*D how patronising!!! I don't need 'pink' websites, I don't need 'empathetic' websites, I need what everyone else needs. Simple, clear easy to navigate websites with decent products at competitive prices (assuming I'm shopping for items) or websites with good, quality information on them. Simples!

Comment: 14

As a woman, I´ve felt curious about the article title.
I can tell that the firts two examples of Dodge and Dell are very much insulting.

BUT after reading the whole article, I feel a little insulted myself, because the author didn´t get the point right: Women want the same thing that men: function over stupidity. The author himself has pointed that out, but it fails to deliver.

Why? Because if that statement (women want function and features first) is true (and I think it is), it is plain silly to talk about designing for women!!
You just have to do a great design, it doesn´t matter if you´re designing for men, women, or little green martians.

When we shop online, we want to be able to search products fast, to be able to filter results by product characteristics, price, location (ie. when is being sell in different shops), etc.
When we find two or more results that interest us, we like to compare it´s characteristics easily and fast, have complete information, and if we purchase something, we want a fast and clear experience.

If I´m not very much mistaken, men want the same thing when they shop online.

Victoria
Buenos Aires

Comment: 15

Registered an account just to say the author needs to get out of tech stat. It's hard enough for women in tech without women in the field perpetuating this kind of garbage.

Comment: 16

Though I really enjoyed the examples given in this article, the only real actionable content I found was "Emphasise benefits over features or specs". I'm going to review these other guidelines you gave to hopefully dig a little deeper.

What I care about most are design aesthetics and specific examples of A/B results in e-commerce. It'd also be fascinating to see if women prefer certain navigation types, content styles... typography etc.
July issue on sale now!

The Week in Web Design

Sign up to our 'Week in Web Design' newsletter!

Hosting Directory
.net digital edition
Treat yourself to our geeky merchandise!
site stat collection